No, That Trump-Russia Dossier Is NOT an Elaborate 4chan Hoax

In spite of rumors being spread on pro-Donald Trump and alt-right websites, there is absolutely no evidence that the document posted by Buzzfeed detailing an alleged link between Trump and Russia is “an elaborate 4chan hoax.”

Townhall published a piece entitled “Did 4Chan Troll The CIA?” which was later picked up by the Drudge Report alongside posts from conspiratorial and alt-right sites. By Wednesday, it was gospel among the Trump faithful that 4chan was behind it all.

But the notion that 4chan was the source for the memo or any of the information in it is more than just baseless– it’s easily disproved.

The supposed “proof” for the 4chan genesis theory was a November 1 post on 4chan’s /pol/ board in which an anonymous user claimed he gave Republican “Never Trump” operative Rick Wilson a fake story about Trump and Russian spies.

4chan

That’s certainly vague to begin with, but note the date: November 1. Mother Jones was reporting on the memo as early as October 30. In a tweet, MJ’s David Corn confirmed that the memo published by Buzzfeed was the same one he received… before the supposed trolling.

More to the point, everything we know about the memo’s source from CNN and The New York Times contradicts the notion that it could possibly be 4chan or Wilson. According to those outlets:

  • The intelligence community knows who the source is, and considers him generally reliable
  • The author of the memo is ex-British intelligence, with extensive Russian contacts
  • The intelligence community also knows his cources and considers them”credible”
  • Some of the memos were circulating as early as the summer of 2016

Some /pol/lacks (uh, their term, not mine) have gotten around these inconvenient facts by claiming Wilson used independent presidential candidate Evan McMullin as an intermediary. But again, McMullin is ex-CIA, not MI6.

Wilson himself came out and bluntly said he wasn’t Buzzfeed’s source. “I’ll settle it this way; if — arguendo — I had been their source, I hereby release the authors of the story, its editors, and BuzzFeed generally from any off-the-record/background protections of anonymity I would have asked for,” he said. Since Buzzfeed hasn’t subsequently come out and named Wilson as their source, it seems likely it wasn’t him.

Does that mean the memo is accurate? That’s still inconclusive. But what is conclusive is that the intelligence community knows enough about the source of the allegations to consider them credible and worth investigating, and that some anonymous guy on 4chan almost certainly had nothing to do with it.

Will that stop Drudge, the alt-right, 4chan, Trump, and his supporters from claiming otherwise? Of course not.


Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


4 + = 5